top of page

MODULE 8 - SCORECARD



Introduction to the Balanced Scorecard


The Balanced Scorecard, conceived in the early 1990s by Drs. Robert Kaplan and David Norton, represents a holistic approach to strategic management. More than just a measurement tool, it serves as a comprehensive management system, guiding organizations in clarifying their vision, translating it into actionable strategies, and continuously improving performance.


Four Perspectives of the Balanced Scorecard:


The Balanced Scorecard advocates for evaluating organizations from four perspectives:


1. Financial Perspective: Traditionally, financial metrics have been pivotal in gauging performance. Key indicators include operating income and return-on-capital-employed, providing insights into the effectiveness of strategy execution.

2. Customer Perspective: Understanding customer needs and preferences is crucial for business success. Metrics such as market share, customer satisfaction, and retention help assess customer-centric performance.

3. Internal Business Processes Perspective: Effective internal processes drive organizational efficiency and innovation. Analysis of product design, development, and operations management aids in identifying areas for improvement and strategic focus.

4. Learning and Growth Perspective: Continuous adaptation and development are essential for organizational survival. Metrics related to employee satisfaction, retention, skills, and organizational learning capabilities enable firms to evolve in dynamic markets.


Balanced Scorecard Compared to Other Management Approaches:

Approach

Age of Approach

Goal Definition

Focus

Scope

Plans

Management Activities

Measures of Success

Project Management

Decades

Project Requirements

Technical Mission

Specialized unit

Plan of Action & Milestones

Team building, Budgeting, Task Tracking, Reviews

Deliverables on time, on budget

Business Process Improvement

Began in 1992

Mission Needs Statement

Business Processes

Unit to Enterprise

Process Improvement Plan

Baseline process analysis, to-be process design, automation

Cost reductions minus cost of BPI effort

Balanced Scorecard

Began in 1990

Strategic management system

Multiple perspectives

Dept. to Enterprise

Strategic Plan, Performance Plan

Define metrics, collect data, analyze data, decide on changes

Learning what strategies work; improved results on many metrics

Key Features of the Balanced Scorecard:


The Balanced Scorecard methodology integrates principles from Total Quality Management, emphasizing customer-defined quality, continuous improvement, and measurement-based management. It incorporates double-loop feedback, outcome metrics, and management by fact to facilitate strategic decision-making and performance improvement.


Balanced Scorecard Implementation:


The implementation of the Balanced Scorecard involves two phases: building the scorecard and implementing it throughout the organization. The six-step framework for scorecard development includes organizational assessment, defining strategies, defining strategic objectives, creating a strategic map, developing performance measures, and identifying new initiatives. The implementation phase focuses on automation, communicating corporate strategy, and continuous evaluation and adaptation.


Deployment of the Balanced Scorecard Measurement System:


Deploying the Balanced Scorecard requires effective change management and the establishment of continuous data flows for downward and upward information dissemination. The system enables organizations to align goals, track performance, and drive strategic success through learning, process improvements, customer satisfaction, and financial management.


Critical Questions

To verify the design of the initial BSC, we could ask the following questions of every strategic initiative:

 

Alignment questions:

 

  • What is the strategic goal that is being addressed by this activity?

  • What organizational mission does it relate to?

  • Do we have a hypothesis as to how this initiative will eventually improve results (i.e. a strategy map)?

 

Baseline questions:

 

  • What is the existing level of performance? Do we know?

  • Are we collecting data and storing it somewhere?

  • What are the statistical parameters of this data, e.g. how random is it? (Baseline)

 

Cost and risk questions:

 

  • What is the existing cost of operation?

  • How much will that increase when we do the initiative?

  • What is the risk that this cost will be exceeded?

  • Is the money being spent on this initiative the best use of the funds, or is there a better usage?

  • What is the risk that the initiative will fail?

 

Outcome questions:

 

  • Who are the customers/stakeholders who will benefit directly from this initiative?

  • Who will benefit indirectly?

  • Is the specified initiative the best way to increase customer satisfaction, or is there a better way?

  • How will we know that the initiative benefits these customers?

 

Metrics questions:

 

  • What metrics will be used to define the benefit?

  • Are these the best metrics?

  • How will we know that?

  • Are the metrics standardized, so they can be benchmarked against performance in other organizations?

 

Measurement Methodology questions:

 

  • How will the metrics be measured? What methods will be used, and how frequently will data be collected?

  • Is this the best way to do the measurements?

  • How will we know that?

 

Results questions:

 

  • How can we demonstrate that this strategic initiative, and not something else, contributed to a change in results?

  • How much of the change was probably random?


Challenges and Best Practices:


Challenges in implementing the Balanced Scorecard include resistance to measurement, lack of common definitions, inconsistent buy-in, and poorly defined strategies. Best practices involve limiting the number of measures, seeking balance among perspectives, setting stretch targets, and holding individuals accountable for results.


The Balanced Scorecard offers a comprehensive framework for strategic management, enabling organizations to translate vision into action, improve performance, and achieve long-term success in today's dynamic business environment.


The Balanced Scorecard represents a comprehensive approach to strategic management, integrating financial, customer, internal process, and learning perspectives. By aligning goals, tracking performance, and fostering a culture of continuous improvement, organizations can enhance their competitive advantage and achieve long-term success in today's complex business landscape.


Balance Scorecard Challenges Detailed

 

  • Fear of measurement and new systems

  • Lack of common definitions and terms

  • Inconsistent or weak buy-in, and lack of understanding

  • Visions and strategies that are poorly defined and understood, not

  • actionable, and not linked to individual actions

  • Treating budgeting as separate from strategy development

  • Measures that are set independently of the performance framework,

  • or measures with no ownership

  • No performance targets, or targets that are set too high or too low

  • Little or no strategic feedback

  • Lack of meaningful employee involvement

 

Best Practices in Balance Scorecard Technique Detailed

 

  • Limit the number of measures

  • Include measures for all perspectives and all strategies

  • Seek balance among measures

  • Develop solid baseline date

  • Develop measures for past, present, and future

  • Don’t over-rely on output, process and input measures

  • Set stretch targets

  • Hold people accountable for results


The Balanced Scorecard and Knowledge Management:


Recent interest in knowledge management emphasizes the importance of people, learning, improved processes, and customer satisfaction in achieving strategic success. The Balanced Scorecard aligns with this perspective, highlighting the interconnectedness of learning and growth, business process improvements, customer loyalty, and financial outcomes. By fostering a culture of learning, encouraging employee involvement, and prioritizing customer relationships, organizations can enhance their strategic performance.


Balanced Scorecard Challenges:


Implementing the Balanced Scorecard presents various challenges, including fear of measurement, lack of common definitions, inconsistent buy-in, and poorly defined strategies. Overcoming these challenges requires robust change management, clear communication, and alignment of goals across all levels of the organization.


Best Practices in Balanced Scorecard Technique:


To maximize the effectiveness of the Balanced Scorecard, organizations should adhere to best practices such as limiting the number of measures, seeking balance among perspectives, setting stretch targets, and holding individuals accountable for results. These practices ensure that the Balanced Scorecard remains a valuable tool for strategic decision-making and performance improvement.


Deployment of the Balanced Scorecard Measurement System:


Successful deployment of the Balanced Scorecard requires effective change management and strategic alignment. By initiating pilot projects, defining clear goals and metrics, and establishing continuous data flows, organizations can ensure that the Balanced Scorecard becomes an integral part of their strategic management process. Additionally, leveraging information technology and fostering open communication channels are essential for driving organizational alignment and performance improvement.


The Balanced Scorecard offers a holistic approach to strategic management, enabling organizations to translate their vision into action and drive sustainable performance improvement. By focusing on key perspectives, aligning goals, and fostering a culture of learning and innovation, organizations can navigate complex business environments and achieve their long-term objectives. Embracing the principles of the Balanced Scorecard empowers organizations to adapt to change, seize opportunities, and thrive in an increasingly competitive marketplace.


References:


- Kaplan, R. S., & Norton, D. P. (1996). The Balanced Scorecard: Translating Strategy into Action. Harvard Business Press.

- Kaplan, R. S., & Norton, D. P. (2007). Using the Balanced Scorecard as a Strategic Management System. Harvard Business Review.

- Niven, P. R. (2003). Balanced Scorecard Step-by-Step: Maximizing Performance and Maintaining Results. John Wiley & Sons.



2 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Commentaires


bottom of page